Daves v. Dallas County- Update- 5th Circuit Issues Stunning Rebuke of Plaintiffs and ODonnell Case


Shocking News.  The Fifth Circuit handed down the long awaited opinion in the Daves case today.  The court starts the opinion by stating the following:

"In a second round of en banc review, we conclude that this case, whose aim was to revise by federal decree the Texas state court pocedures for felony and misdemenaor pretrial bail, should neer have been brought in federal court."

This is the second en banc decision handed down by the 5th Circuit in the case.  The court remands the case with instructions to DISMISS.

The court holds that the trial court should have abstained from hearing the case.

To see the opinion CLICK HERE.

This is a rapidly moving story.  More to follow.

Impressions-

ODonnell should never have been filed.  The county has spent over $100 million to implement a settlement that the trial court 

How does this impact the Russell v. Harris County case pending in federal court in Houston?

How does this impact the Booth v. Galveston County case pending at the 5th Circuit on appeal from Galaveston federal court.

More to come . . .


Comments

Post a Comment

Most Read Posts Over The Last 30 Days

Saddle Up for the 2026 PBT Convention

Image
Get ready for three exciting days of education, networking, entertainment, and Texas- sized hospitality! The Professional Bondsmen of Texas (PBT) proudly invites members, industry professionals, exhibitors, sponsors, and friends to join us for the 2026 PBT Convention, October 21-23, in beautiful San Antonio. This year’s Annual Professional Bondsmen of Texas Convention theme is Bail Boots with Texas Roots! We are writing today because we want you to know that YOU MATTER to us! Professional Bondsman of Texas is the principal advocate and leadership organization for the bail industry in Texas!   Do not forget the Annual Skeet Shoot at the San Antonio Gun Club!! Enjoy some 3B Texas BBQ and dessert for lunch. Transportation has been arranged through Star Shuttle to take you from the hotel to the event. Lunch will begin 12:30-1:30pm, Teams will begin shooting at 1:30 for a game of WizBang with 50 targets and 2 boxes of ammo included per shooter. We have reserved 5 rental ...
Read more

The Bail Post Episode 77- SB 9 Spotlight- Changes to Article 17.03 of the Tex. Code Crim. Pro.

Image
In SB 6 and SB 9, the Texas Legislature made major changes to article 17.03 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure.  On this episode of the Bail Post we begin a new series placing a spotlight on changes to the Criminal Justice System of Texas that are set out in SB 9, SB 6 and several other statutes passed by the Texas Legislature. We will be highlightiing changes to Article 17.03 regarding the use of personal bonds in Texas.  In SB 6 the changes to article 17.03 was one of three major reforms set out in the bill.  In SB 9, artilce 17.03 was tweaked by adding an additional charge on which a defendant is not entitle to a persona bond (felon in possession of a weapon) and one charge was moved from group 3 to to group 2 (terroristic threat). PBT has a one page summary of the charges and their restrictions set out in article 17.03.  The document can be downloaded using the following LINK . Additionally, if you would like additional information regarding the YOLO County ...
Read more

Using a Buzz Saw to Cut Butter- Tennessee's Proposed Constitutional Amendment No 1 to Expand Preventative Detention

Image
On this episode of The Bail Post we look at the proposed Constitutional Amendment No. 1 for the State of Tennessee that will be on the ballot in November and its proposal to expand preventative detention.  Our guests are Shelly Alexander and Eric Granof.   Audio Podcast- Also available on- Apple Podcasts-            CLICK HERE Spotify-                        CLICK HERE Google Podcasts-        CLICK HERE Podcast Index-            CLICK HERE Amazon Music-          CLICK HERE Stitcher-                      CLICK HERE iHeart-                        CLICK HERE TuneIn + Alexa          CLICK HERE Podc...
Read more

Episode No. 78- ODonnell v. Harris County- The Case That Will Not Die- Is The End Finally Coming?

Image
On October 5, 2026, the Honorable Judge Lee Rosenthal issued an memorandum opinion in the ODonnell case.  The court was ruling on a motion to dismiss the consent decree that was filed by 4 of the 16 misdemeanor judges.   By way of history, the judges had been arguing for sometime that the consent decree did not comply with SB 6 and more recently did not comply with SB 9 passed by the Texas Legislature in the most recent Texas Legislative Session.  Additionally, since the consent decree/settlement agreement was entered, all of the substantive rulings made by the trial court in ODonnell had been reversed by the 5th Circuit.  Further, in the Daves II en banc opinion issued by the 5th Circuit, the court of appeals specifically stated that both Daves and ODonnell should never have been adjudicated in federal court. The trial court issued her opinion because the 5th Circuit issued a writ of mandamus ordering Judge Rosenthal to rule on the motion to dismiss based upon Young...
Read more

Special Guest for PBT Annual Meeting- Beverly Vance Aikins

Image
  Beverly Vance Aikins is a recovery advocate, speaker, and mentor whose life story embodies redemption, resilience, and the power of second chances. Known for her warmth, honesty, and deep compassion, Beverly shares her journey to inspire individuals, families, churches, and communities seeking healing and hope. For many years, Beverly struggled with addiction to prescription pain medication, eventually leading to harder substances. Her story reflects the experience of countless American families — pain, coping, and a gradual slide into dependency that once felt impossible to escape. Through faith, community, and a fierce determination to rebuild her life, Beverly entered recovery and began a new chapter grounded in grace and purpose. She is also the mother of Vice President J.D. Vance, author of Hillbilly Elegy, the bestselling memoir later adapted into a Netflix film directed by Ron Howard. While millions know the Vance family story, Beverly’s voice is uniquely her own — rooted ...
Read more

Stories by Topic:

Show more