Texas Court of Criminal Appeals- It is Error To Not Consider The Public Safety Report


On December 6, 2023, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals handed down an opinion in Cause No. PD-0513-23; Ex Parte Gayosso; In the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.  The case arose from Waller County and was presented to the court on a Petition for Discretionary Review from the 14th Court of Appeals.  

The case dealt with the Damon Allen Act which requires that a "public safety report" be prepared when a magistrate is considering the release on bail of a person charged with a Class B misdemeanor offense or higher.  The Court noted that the statute requires the magistrate to "conside" the report before setting bail.

On appeal, the Court noted that the court of appeals "appears not to have reviewed the public safety report."  The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals held that this was error.

The first part of the opinion dealt with the effective date of the Damon Allen Act which was January 1, 2022.  Further, the Court noted that the Act contained an exemption that stated that a magistrate or judge is exempt from having to consider the public safety report during a bail consideration that took place before April 1, 2022.  Therefore, the defendant was arrested after the effective date of the Act.  Further, the first magistration took place during the exemption period.  However, the hearing to reconsider the bail set by the court was held on June 16, 2022.  

Therefore, the Court of Criminal Appeals held that the trial court was required to consider the Public Safety Report in considering the motion to reconsider.  Not considering the public safety report was error.  Further, a court of appeals errs in not reviewing the Public Safety Report in an appeal.

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals refused the petition without prejudice.  Additionally, the court, on its own motions, vacated the court of appeals' decision and remanded the case to the court of appeals for further proceedings.  The decision was unanimous.

To see a copy of the opinion from the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals CLICK HERE.



Comments

  1. robert herreraDecember 13, 2023 at 5:42 PM

    How significant is this error? What are the consequences for a magistrate that doesn’t wait/ consider the public safety report before setting bail?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ken W. GoodDecember 15, 2023 at 9:24 AM

    This case says that the trial court commits error if they do not consider the public safety report. Since setting bail is reviewed on an abuse of discretion standard, I believe that this means that if the court does not review the public safety report, it is an abuse of discretion.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ken W. GoodJanuary 18, 2024 at 3:08 PM

    Bail is reviewed on an abuse of discretion standard. Failing to follow the law is a part of the review. So the trial court's decision to not review the public safety report would be reviewed de novo and and would be error and failing to follow the law would be an abuse of discretion requiring reversal.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Most Read Posts Over The Last 30 Days

The Bail Post Episode No. 55- New York's Deal With The Devil Over Recidivism With Guest Jim Quinn

Image
Jim Quinn is a former assistant district attorney in Queens, New York. His family has lived in New York for four generations. Jim was on the front lines as New York slipped bail reform into the budget bill in 2019 and when it went into effect in January 2020. Jim has written numerous articles about the New York bail reform and its impact on crime. On this episode of The Bail Post we evaluate the reforms and their impact on recidivism. The biggest take away from this episode is that the politicians stated that they were willing to have more crime to address their political agenda. Four years later, we can say that they got exactly that. Crime is up 40% since before the reforms were enacted and defendants with a prior arrest are committing new crimes at record numbers. Recidivism rates demonstrate that a known group of people are committing a large percentage of crimes and the citizens are bearing the brunt of the harm because politicians refuse to fix the problems that they them
Read more

Good People, Good Food, Good Conversation and Good Competition- PBT's Upcoming 2024 Spring Fling

Image
Wednesday: April 10 - 12 is the PBT 8th Annual Spring Fling.  Festivities will begin on Wednesday with the Annual PBT Golf tournament.  Additionally, as teams are playing golf, another PBT team will be preparing a feast for Wednesday evening.  Late Wednesday afternoon PBT will celebrate the victors of the golf tournament with its annual cook out dinner.  This is a great time to mingle with other bondsmen, our lobbyists and our surety partners as we have fun celebrating all things Texas. Additionally, PBT invites local law enforcement members to join in the fun. This year, Wednesday evening will see a new element to the celebration.  PBT is sponsoring its first ever steak cook off  competition.  PBT currently has thirteen entries who are willing to put their reputations on the line to find out who can cook the best steak as selected by our blue ribbon panel of judges.  The cooks will be performing under the harsh lights (and harsh jokes) of all the spectators supporting and heckling the
Read more

The Bail Post Episode No. 54: The Causes of Crime and How to Deter It With Guest Dr. Jennifer Wooldridge

Image
On this episode of The Bail Post we talk about the current theories regarding the causes of crime and how to deter it.  Our guest is Dr. Jennifer Wooldridge.  She is an associate professor of Criminal Justice and the Criminal Justice Undergraduate Coordinator at UT Tyler.   Audio Podcast- Also available on: Apple Podcasts-            CLICK HERE Spotify-                        CLICK HERE Google Podcasts-        CLICK HERE Podcast Index-            CLICK HERE Amazon Music-          CLICK HERE Stitcher-                      CLICK HERE iHeart-                        CLICK HERE TuneIn + Alexa          CLICK HERE Podcast Addict-          CLICK HERE Podchaser-                  CLICK HERE Pocket Casts-              CLICK HERE Deezer-                       CLICK HERE   Listen Notes-             CLICK HERE Audible-                     CLICK HERE PlayerFM-                 CLICK HERE Video version of Podcast- Subject Index to The Bail Post Podcast-   CLICK HERE   To find more information regarding
Read more

The Pendulum of Justice: Let ‘em out, Lock ‘em up

Image
  Over the past decade we have witnessed a giant swing of the pendulum in the criminal justice system from tough on crime policies to soft on crime policies and back again. These erratic swings have been created by knee jerk reactions by legislators to fix what they refer to as problems and inequities in the criminal justice system. Unfortunately, these fixes have consistently failed, in fact, creating even larger imbalances that then need another fix which then also goes too far…and so on and so on. For example, for many years we heard cries from activist groups that “jails are overcrowded.” They claimed we had too many people in jail for low level crimes and the only reason they were there was because they could not afford a bail bond. This narrative became the fuel behind an entire criminal justice movement that most of us know as “bail reform”. The blame for overcrowding was put solely on people’s ability to pay bail. So, the reaction of legislators (and some DAs) was to release mo
Read more

The Bail Post Episode No. 52: The Legacy of Daves v. Dallas County

Image
The United States Supreme Court denied the petition for cert. filed by the plaintiffs in Daves v. Dallas County in January.  In February, the United States Supreme Court filed another petition for cert. filed in Little v. Doguet from Louisiana on a similar issue.  Therefore, the Daves v. Dallas County case has finally been concluded.  On this episode of The Bail Post we discuss the legacy of this case and the other important case called ODonnell v. Harris County.  Audio Podcast-   Also available on: Apple Podcasts-            CLICK HERE Spotify-                        CLICK HERE Google Podcasts-        CLICK HERE Podcast Index-            CLICK HERE Amazon Music-          CLICK HERE Stitcher-                      CLICK HERE iHeart-                        CLICK HERE TuneIn + Alexa          CLICK HERE Podcast Addict-          CLICK HERE Podchaser-                  CLICK HERE Pocket Casts-              CLICK HERE Deezer-                       CLICK HERE   Listen Notes-             CLICK H
Read more

Stories by Topic:

Show more